The Gas House Gang: Baseball's Rowdiest Champions (1934) [Part 1]

INTRODUCTION
The 1934 St. Louis Cardinals weren't just a great baseball team – they were a collection of unforgettable characters who created stories and legends that have endured for nearly nine decades. While their statistics and achievements are impressive, it's the colorful personalities and wild tales surrounding the Gas House Gang that truly set them apart in Cardinals history.
From their unconventional appearances to their clubhouse shenanigans, from their on-field antics to their off-field adventures, the Gas House Gang left behind a treasure trove of baseball folklore that continues to captivate fans. Let's explore the stories and personalities that made this team unlike any other in Cardinals history.
THE ORIGINS OF A NICKNAME
The "Gas House Gang" nickname itself has become part of baseball lore, though its exact origins remain somewhat disputed. The most common explanation traces the name to the team's disheveled appearance and rough-and-tumble style, reminiscent of the tough characters who lived near gas manufacturing plants in urban areas.
When the Cardinals arrived in Detroit for the 1934 World Series, legend has it that a local sportswriter took one look at their unshaven faces, wrinkled uniforms, and general scruffiness and remarked they looked like they'd come straight from the gas house district. The name stuck instantly.
Pepper Martin (3B, STL), the team's third baseman, embraced the nickname with pride. "We were just a bunch of wild-eyed country boys," he later recalled. "We didn't dress up and we didn't put on airs. When they called us the Gas House Gang, we loved it. That's exactly what we were – rough, tough, and not afraid of anything."
The Cardinals' appearance wasn't just casual -- it was deliberately unkempt. Players often went days without shaving. They slid hard into bases with no concern for keeping their uniforms clean. By the late innings of a game, they looked like they'd been in a bar fight rather than a baseball contest.
Manager Frankie Frisch, despite his own more polished background (he'd attended Fordham University), understood the psychological advantage this rough appearance created. Opponents would look across the field and see a team that appeared more ready for a street fight than a baseball game. This intimidation factor became part of the team's identity and strategy.
THE PITCHING STAFF: THE DEAN BROTHERS AND COMPANY
The 1934 Cardinals' success started with their pitching, particularly the brother act that dominated National League hitters throughout the season.
Jay Hanna "Dizzy" Dean (RHP, STL) was the unquestioned ace and the team's most colorful character. In 1934, Dizzy put together one of the greatest pitching seasons of the era, going 30-7 with a 2.66 ERA. His 30 wins led the majors, as did his 195 strikeouts. Dean completed 24 of his 33 starts and threw 311.2 innings, showcasing the durability that defined pitchers of that era.
By modern metrics, Dean's season looks even more impressive. His ERA+ of 159 meant he was 59% better than the average pitcher when adjusting for park factors and era. His WHIP (walks plus hits per inning pitched) was an excellent 1.165. Dean struck out 8.6% of batters he faced while walking just 2.3%, giving him an outstanding strikeout-to-walk ratio of 2.60. His 8.9 WAR (Wins Above Replacement) ranked as one of the highest single-season totals for a pitcher in Cardinals history.
What made Dean special wasn't just his blazing fastball, but his pinpoint control. Unlike many power pitchers of his era, Dean rarely beat himself with walks. His walk rate of 2.2 per nine innings was remarkably low for a strikeout pitcher in the 1930s.
Paul "Daffy" Dean (RHP, STL), Dizzy's younger brother, proved to be much more than a sideshow. In his rookie season, Paul went 19-11 with a 3.43 ERA. He was a better strikeout artist than initially thought, with 5.8 K/9, while maintaining excellent control (2.0 BB/9). His ERA+ of 123 and WAR of 5.1 confirmed he was an above-average starter in his own right.
Together, the Dean brothers accounted for 49 of the Cardinals' 95 wins -- an astounding 52% of the team's total victories. They combined for 545 innings pitched, approximately 39% of the team's total innings. Both were equally effective in the World Series, with Paul throwing a complete game victory in Game 3 and Dizzy dominating in the decisive Game 7.
The rest of the pitching staff was solid if unspectacular. Bill Walker (LHP, STL) (12-4, 3.12 ERA), Tex Carleton (RHP, STL) (16-11, 4.26 ERA), and Bill Hallahan (LHP, STL) (8-12, 4.26 ERA) rounded out the rotation. The bullpen was anchored by Jesse Haines (RHP, STL) and Bill Walker, though complete games were far more common then, with Cardinals starters finishing 78 of their 154 games.
THE INFIELD: SKILL, SWAGGER, AND SLICK FIELDING
The Cardinals' infield combined defensive excellence with solid offensive production, forming the backbone of the team's success.
First baseman Jim "Ripper" Collins (1B, STL) had his finest season in 1934, hitting .333/.393/.615 with 35 home runs, 128 RBIs, and 116 runs scored. His power numbers were exceptional – he led the team in home runs while adding 40 doubles and 12 triples. Collins' .615 slugging percentage ranked second in the National League, and his 1.008 OPS placed him third. His .282 ISO (Isolated Power, which measures raw power by subtracting batting average from slugging percentage) showed he was one of the league's premier power hitters. Advanced metrics confirm Collins' elite season: 158 OPS+, 6.4 WAR.
Second baseman Frankie Frisch (2B, STL), the player-manager known as "The Fordham Flash," continued to excel at age 36. Frisch hit .305/.359/.398 with 3 home runs and 75 RBIs. While his power had diminished from his prime years, Frisch remained an excellent contact hitter with just 10 strikeouts in 606 plate appearances. His baserunning added value with 11 stolen bases, and his defense at second base remained strong. Overall, Frisch contributed 2.8 WAR while simultaneously managing the team – a remarkable dual role.
Shortstop Leo Durocher (SS, STL), nicknamed "The Lip" for his notorious talking, was known more for his glove than his bat. Durocher hit .260/.308/.350 with limited power, but his defensive contributions were significant. Despite his modest offensive numbers (71 OPS+, 0.3 total WAR), Durocher's leadership and defensive skill made him a key component of the infield.
Third baseman Pepper Martin, "The Wild Horse of the Osage," embodied the Gang's spirited play. Martin hit .289/.337/.425 with 5 home runs, 49 RBIs, and a team-leading 23 stolen bases. His aggressive baserunning and all-out defensive style made him a fan favorite. Martin's 97 OPS+ and 1.9 WAR reflected his solid all-around contributions. His ability to get extra-base hits (25 doubles, 11 triples) showed decent power for a third baseman of that era, particularly one known more for speed than slugging.
The Cardinals' infield combined excellent defense with enough offensive firepower to support their pitching staff. Collectively, the starting infield produced approximately 11.4 WAR, forming the team's backbone both offensively and defensively.
THE OUTFIELD: SLUGGERS AND SPEEDSTERS
The Cardinals' outfield featured a mix of power and speed that perfectly complemented their infield.
Left fielder Joe "Ducky" Medwick (OF, STL) began his ascent to stardom in 1934, hitting .319/.343/.529 with 18 home runs and 106 RBIs. Just 22 years old, Medwick added 40 doubles and 18 triples, showcasing his gap-to-gap power. His .210 ISO, 124 OPS+, and 3.2 WAR confirmed his emergence as one of the league's top young hitters. Though not exceptional defensively, his offensive production more than compensated for any fielding limitations.
Center fielder Ernie Orsatti (OF, STL) split time with Jack Rothrock (OF, STL) but got the majority of starts. Orsatti hit .300/.353/.365 with limited power but added value through his defense and baserunning. His 88 OPS+ made him a slightly below league-average hitter, and his 0.2 WAR reflected his role as a solid if unspectacular contributor.
Right field featured primarily Jack Rothrock (OF, STL), who put together a solid season with a .284/.336/.399 batting line, 11 home runs, and 72 RBIs. Rothrock's 91 OPS+ and 1.3 WAR made him a valuable complementary player. His .115 ISO showed moderate power that helped extend the lineup's offensive threat.
The Cardinals outfield depth proved crucial throughout the season. Beyond the starting trio, Virgil Davis (C, STL) (.300/.366/.464) and Chick Fullis (OF, STL) (.261/.310/.317) provided valuable playing time when needed. The outfield as a unit produced approximately 4.7 WAR, combining with the infield to give the Cardinals a balanced attack.
THE CATCHING CORPS: STEADY HANDS BEHIND THE PLATE
The Cardinals' catching duties were primarily handled by Bill DeLancey (C, STL), with Virgil Davis (C, STL) serving as backup.
DeLancey had his finest season in 1934, hitting .316/.414/.565 with 13 home runs and 40 RBIs. His offensive production was exceptional for a catcher of the 1930sl/ -- his 152 OPS+ ranked among the best for his position. DeLancey's excellent plate discipline showed in his .414 on-base percentage, supported by 41 walks against just 37 strikeouts. His 2.7 WAR made him one of the most valuable catchers in baseball, combining offensive production with solid defense.
Virgil Davis provided quality depth, hitting .300/.366/.464 in 384 plate appearances. With good power (.164 ISO), Davis made consistent contact and handled pitchers well. His 115 OPS+ and 1.8 WAR made him an above-average backup catcher.
The Cardinals' catching corps combined for approximately 4.5 WAR, providing both offensive production and the steady game-calling that helped the pitching staff excel. DeLancey's ability to handle the unique personalities and pitching styles of the Dean brothers proved particularly valuable throughout the season.
TEAM PERFORMANCE: THE NUMBERS BEHIND THE NICKNAME
Beyond the individual performances, the Cardinals' team statistics reveal just how good this squad really was.
Offensively, the Gas House Gang scored 799 runs (second in the National League) with a team batting line of .288/.344/.428. Their collective 108 OPS+ indicated they were 8% better than the league average offensively after accounting for park factors. The Cardinals hit 94 home runs (third in the NL) while adding 267 doubles and 86 triples. They stole 68 bases and drew 430 walks against just 393 strikeouts – one of the few teams in history to walk more often than they struck out.
On the pitching side, the Cardinals posted a 3.69 team ERA (third in the NL). The staff struck out 689 batters while walking just 411, giving them an excellent strikeout-to-walk ratio of 1.68. Their team WHIP of 1.351 ranked third in the league. When adjusting for the hitter-friendly era, their 115 ERA+ confirmed they were 15% better than the league average.
Defensively, the Cardinals converted 68.5% of balls in play into outs (Defensive Efficiency), ranking fourth in the National League. While defensive metrics from this era are limited, contemporary accounts praised the Cardinals' infield defense, particularly the Frisch-Durocher combination up the middle.
Over the 154-game season, the Cardinals went 95-58 with one tie, for a .621 winning percentage. Their Pythagorean record (based on runs scored and allowed) was 94-59, indicating their actual performance aligned almost perfectly with their underlying statistics.
What's particularly impressive about the 1934 Cardinals is that they won the pennant despite facing significant competition. The New York Giants went 93-60, finishing just 2 games behind St. Louis after leading the race for much of the season. The Cardinals' furious 14-2 finish, including 7 straight wins to close the season, allowed them to overtake the Giants in dramatic fashion.
THE SECRET SAUCE: WHAT MADE THE GAS HOUSE GANG SPECIAL
Beyond the numbers, several factors made the 1934 Cardinals a truly special team.
First was their resilience. Trailing the Giants by 7 games on September 6 with just 22 games remaining, most teams would have conceded the pennant. The Gas House Gang instead mounted one of baseball's greatest comebacks, going 18-4 down the stretch while the Giants faltered.
Second was their chemistry -- though perhaps not in the traditional sense. The Cardinals argued, fought, and challenged each other constantly, but this competitive internal dynamic seemed to fuel rather than hinder their performance. When Dizzy Dean and Joe Medwick scuffled in the dugout during a game, it represented the team's fiery nature rather than a real problem.
Third was their tactical approach. Under Frisch's guidance, the Cardinals played an aggressive style that maximized their athletic advantages. They took extra bases, executed hit-and-runs, and generally pressured opponents into mistakes. This approach was particularly effective in an era before specialized relievers, when forcing a starting pitcher out of the game early could create significant advantages.
Fourth was their connection with St. Louis fans. In the depths of the Depression, the Gas House Gang's working-class image and playing style resonated deeply with a city facing economic hardship. The players weren't ‘company men’ but relatable figures who played with visible passion. Think blue-collar – the 1930s version.
Finally, there was the Dizzy Dean factor. Beyond his brilliant pitching, Dean's oversized personality and constant promotion of the team created national interest in the Cardinals. His colorful quotes, bold predictions, and willingness to speak to any reporter made the Cardinals the most talked-about team in baseball – and Dean made sure his teammates received their share of the spotlight.